melody over chords, no rhythm

  • a scale step sounds different depending on the chord it's played over
    • play scale step 1 over (at the same time as) the 1 chord, then over the 4 chord, then over the 5 chord
    • notice how different the scale step sounds when you change the chord under it
  • it's very similar to the effect of one color on another
    • a pink scarf or tie looks different depending on what other colors you're wearing
  • when you play the 7 scale steps one at a time over a chord, some scale steps sound calm and some sound tense
  • when you change the chord, a scale step that sounded calm may now sound tense
the 7 scale steps over the 1 chord (scale steps in the 1 chord: 1, 3 & 5)
  • play the 7 scale steps one at a time over the 1 chord, noticing how they each sound
  • notice that the scale steps that are in the chord - steps 1, 3 & 5 - sound the most calm
  • play scale steps 2, 6 & 7 one at a time over the 1 chord
    • they sound less calm but (to me, at least) not very tense
  • play scale step 4 over the 1 chord
    • it sounds very tense to most people
step    tension
1       lowest (it's in the chord)
3       lowest (it's in the chord)
5       lowest (it's in the chord)
6       low (think of the first "you" in Sam Cooke's "You Send Me")
2       medium
7       medium
4       very high

the 7 scale steps over the 4 chord (scale steps in the 4 chord: 4, 6 & 1)

step    tension
4       lowest (it's in the chord)
6       lowest (it's in the chord)
1       lowest (it's in the chord)
2       low
5       medium
3       medium
7       high

the 7 scale steps over the 5 chord (scale steps in the 5 chord: 5, 7 & 2)

step    tension
5       lowest (it's in the chord)
7       lowest (it's in the chord)
2       lowest (it's in the chord)
4       low (it's in a commonly used chord, called the 5 seventh chord)
6       medium
3       medium
1       very high